Correction: Confederate Monument-Protest-Lawsuits storyOctober 17, 2017 5:02pm

In a story Oct. 12 about two lawsuits filed against white nationalists and other groups who descended on Charlottesville in August, The Associated Press erroneously reported a request in one of the lawsuits. The suit filed in federal court does not seek a ban on similar gatherings, but asks the court to prohibit the white nationalists and other groups from committing further civil rights violations.

A corrected version of the story is below:

New lawsuits aim to prevent more violence in Charlottesville

The city of Charlottesville is joining a lawsuit that seeks a court order prohibiting illegal paramilitary activity after white nationalists and militia groups descended on the Virginia city in August for a violent rally


Associated Press

Two newly filed lawsuits against the white nationalists and others who descended on Charlottesville during a summer rally aim to prevent the type of violent chaos that unfolded from happening again.

One of the lawsuits was filed Thursday in Charlottesville Circuit Court on behalf of the city, local businesses and neighborhood associations. It accuses organizers of the August "Unite the Right" rally, leading figures in the white nationalist movement and their organizations, as well as private militia groups and their leaders, of violating Virginia law by organizing and acting as paramilitary units.

It doesn't seek monetary damages but asks for a court order prohibiting "illegal paramilitary activity."

"Touted as an opportunity to protest the removal of a controversial Confederate statue, the event quickly escalated well beyond such constitutionally protected expression," the lawsuit says. "Instead, private military forces transformed an idyllic college town into a virtual combat zone."

Separately, 11 residents injured in the violence filed a lawsuit overnight in federal court in Charlottesville against a number of rally leaders and attendees. News of that lawsuit was first reported by The Washington Post.

The rally drew hundreds of white nationalists to Charlottesville, as well as hundreds of counterprotesters. The two sides began brawling in the streets before the rally got underway, throwing punches, unleashing chemical sprays and setting off smoke bombs. At least one person fired a gun. Later, a woman was killed when a car drove into a crowd protesting the white nationalists.

The lawsuit filed in state court reconstructs the events of the day in detail, citing social media posts of the defendants, media accounts and documents.

It says the white nationalist organizations weren't functioning as individuals exercising their Second Amendment right to self-defense but as members of a "fighting force."

It asks that they be held in violation of several state laws, including falsely assuming the functions of peace officers. Otherwise, the lawsuit says, "Charlottesville will be forced to relive the frightful spectacle of August 12: an invasion of roving paramilitary bands and unaccountable vigilante peacekeepers."

The plaintiffs are being represented by the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection at Georgetown University and regional law firm MichieHamlett. The Charlottesville City Council voted to join the lawsuit in a special session Thursday morning.

"Our community was invaded by private armies on August 12 and lives were lost," local attorney Lee Livingston said in a statement. "As we search for answers and a way forward together, we expect this suit will unify us on at least one thing - a stand against private armies invading the public square - and give our public servants who enforce the law a tool to protect all citizens who gather in public places."

The federal lawsuit takes a different approach, accusing the white nationalists of violating state and federal civil rights laws. It seeks a jury trial, asks for monetary damages and a court ruling prohibiting the white nationalists and other groups from committing further civil rights violations.

"The aim of this lawsuit is to ensure that nothing like this will happen again at the hands of Defendants — not on the streets of Charlottesville, Virginia, and not anywhere else in the United States of America," it says.

The plaintiffs include University of Virginia students, ministers and doctors. One suffered a stroke; two were struck in the car attack.

Their attorneys are Robbie Kaplan, who represented Edith Windsor in the landmark Supreme Court case on gay marriage, and Karen Dunn, a former federal prosecutor in Virginia.

White nationalist Richard Spencer, a defendant in the federal lawsuit, told The Associated Press he had just learned of it and didn't have any immediate comment.

Michael Hill, president of the Southern nationalist League of the South — which is named in both lawsuits — declined comment. So did Jeff Schoep, head of the National Socialist Movement. He and the organization are named in both lawsuits.

No other defendants in the cases, including Jason Kessler, the rally's lead organizer, responded to requests for comment from the AP.

Floyd Abrams, a prominent First Amendment attorney, said the defendants "will certainly claim that everything they did, everything they said, and every action that they took was protected by the First Amendment."

Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz, a leading civil liberties lawyer, cited the First Amendment in calling the lawsuits "very dangerous."

"Everybody hates — as I do — what the white supremacists did in Charlottesville, and because we hate what they did, we may be willing to stretch and bend the First Amendment," he said. "I'm not willing to do this. The First Amendment was designed precisely to protect this kind of unpopular and hateful expression."

But Micah Schwartzman, who teaches constitutional law at the University of Virginia, noted that both lawsuits anticipate claims that the defendants' actions were constitutionally protected and respond to them with evidence.

"These complaints are sophisticated in that way," he said.


AP writers Eric Tucker in Washington; Denise Lavoie in Richmond; and Jay Reeves in Birmingham, Alabama, contributed to this report.

Page 1 of 1

More Stories Like This

FILE - In this Dec. 6, 2016, file photo, Richard Spencer, who leads a movement that mixes racism, white nationalism and populism, speaks at the Texas A&M University campus in College Station, Texas. An associate of Spencer sued Ohio State University after it refused to rent campus space for him to speak. The lawsuit was filed Sunday, Oct. 22, 2017, in federal court in Columbus. (AP Photo/David J. Phillip, File)
Ohio State sued over refusal to let white nationalist speak
Lawyers seek to question neo-Nazi website publisher's familyLawyers suing a neo-Nazi website's publisher are asking for court-ordered permission to question the man's relatives about his whereabouts
More than a dozen states still refuse to release voter dataHow states are handling Trump's voter information request
This combination of photos provided by the Charlottesville Police Department shows 10 suspects that Charlottesville police are searching for. The suspects are wanted in connection with an assault on Aug. 12, 2017, the day a white nationalist rally erupted in violence. Police issued a news release Monday, Oct. 23, asking for the public's assistance identifying the two female and eight male suspects. (Charlottesville Police Department via AP)
10 suspects wanted in assault day of Charlottesville rally
Retrial set for civil rights suit against police officerA judge has scheduled a retrial early next year in a civil rights lawsuit filed by a black man paralyzed when he was shot during a traffic stop by a Pittsburgh police officer
In this Oct. 8, 2017, photo, Zora Gussow, left, waits with a shotgun for a clay target to be thrown during a training session of the Trigger Warning Queer & Trans Gun Club in Victor, N.Y. The members stress they are about empowerment and self-defense, not offense. They say it also gives them a sense of community, even if it comes on a firing line in the middle of farm country. But some veteran activists say they're concerned that this will add to an unnecessary arms race and eventually cause more danger. (AP Photo/Adrian Kraus)
In response to far right, LGBTQ gun group hits firing line
This component is currently unavailable.

Related Searches

Related Searches